In mid-January 2026, the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney under Ryan Mehaffey secured convictions in one of Spotsylvania County’s most violent recent cases — an illegal gun sale that turned into a robbery on Olde Greenwich Circle in April 2025, leaving three young men dead and two more wounded.
The Crime
According to the Commonwealth, four men — Alonzo Goffney, Christopher Moore, Darius Fitz, and Sincere Fitz — allegedly came to Olde Greenwich Circle to illegally buy a gun from Logan Soulier, Jeremiah Upson, and Chase Feaster. The encounter erupted into gunfire.
Three people were killed: Sincere Fitz, 19; Alonzo Goffney, 18; and Chase Feaster, 18. Feaster was shot by an armed neighbor who witnessed the incident; that neighbor was not charged. Two others were wounded — Darius Fitz was shot in the arm, and Christopher Moore suffered gunshot wounds to the face and chest.
The Prosecution
In mid-January 2026, Jeremiah Upson was convicted for his role in the shooting, and four other defendants resolved their cases through plea or trial. The Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney under Ryan Mehaffey prosecuted the matter.
Logan Soulier took his case to trial and was convicted of 24 charges, including second-degree felony murder, three counts of aggravated malicious wounding, four counts of abduction, and ten firearms charges. He was acquitted of two first-degree murder charges. In December, Christopher Moore pleaded guilty to unlawful assembly with a firearm.
Why It Matters
Illegal gun transactions carry the constant risk of exactly this kind of violence — a single deal that ends with young lives lost and families forever changed. The convictions in this case reflect the painstaking work required to hold multiple defendants accountable when a crime scene is chaotic and the roles are tangled.
The outcome is part of the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney’s continuing effort to answer violence in Spotsylvania County with careful, determined prosecution and to protect the community from those who traffic in illegal firearms.
A jury convicted Logan Soulier of 24 charges, including second-degree felony murder, three counts of aggravated malicious wounding, four counts of abduction, and ten firearms charges.